# R3 reading 3 · publication follow-up

New assessment of proposed R3 with the expanded historical statute context. 18 green, 0 yellow, 0 red; all 18 findings parsed and counts reconcile. This is separate from historical readings 1–5. The bill was not enacted; no legislative adoption or practical outcome is implied.

## Policy Summary

The bill repeals the indefinitely confined elector absentee-ballot process beginning January 1, 2029, and replaces it with a written application process under which an eligible elector may automatically receive an absentee ballot for every election held in the elector’s municipality. The elector must provide proof of identification, must notify the municipal clerk if the elector changes address or no longer wants automatic ballots, and may lose automatic-ballot service if the elector fails to return a ballot, subject to a procedure for requesting continued service. Municipal clerks must administer the process, maintain applicable identification records in the statewide voter registration system until the record is no longer needed or the identification expires, notify electors whose identification expires, and notify existing indefinitely confined electors of the transition. The Elections Commission prescribes forms and instructions, and an authorized disability advocate may assist an elector with a disability in transmitting proof of identification. The bill also creates a felony for an authorized disability advocate who knowingly transmits fraudulent proof of identification.

The stated problem is the transition from indefinitely confined elector status to an identification-based automatic absentee-ballot process while preserving automatic ballot delivery for eligible electors. The operative text supplies the responsible institutions, application mechanism, identification requirement, transition notice, record-retention rule, expiration notice, disability-assistance mechanism, discontinuation rules, and penalty. The supplied sources do not establish the number of affected electors, administrative costs, information-technology capacity, the likely effect on ballot access, or the factual incidence of fraudulent submissions. Those are evidence limitations, not findings about the bill’s coherence.

## Review Findings

| Criterion | Color | Structural rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Legitimate Authority | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill expressly amends and creates provisions governing absentee-ballot administration, municipal-clerk duties, Elections Commission forms, and an election-related penalty, providing an identifiable and bounded legislative source for the stated action. |
| Institutional Administration | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — sections 5, 6, 8, 13, 14, 15, 16, and 19 assign applications, notices, ballot delivery, record maintenance, facility procedures, forms, and transition administration to identified election institutions. |
| Public Accountability | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill requires written applications, clerk verification, elector notices, identification-record retention, public-facing transition information, and continued application of existing election administration and enforcement structures. |
| Authority Traceability | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the material exercises of authority are tied to specified statutory sections, municipal clerks, the Elections Commission, the statewide voter registration system, and the newly created penalty provisions. |
| Purpose-Execution Alignment | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the amended automatic-ballot procedure, proof-of-identification requirement, transition notice, and discontinuation rules directly implement the stated replacement of indefinitely confined status with an automatic-ballot application process. |
| Bounded Exercise of Power | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill limits automatic ballot delivery to eligible electors who apply, provide proof of identification, remain qualified, maintain the stated address, and continue to request service, while limiting the new felony to knowing transmission of fraudulent identification by an authorized disability advocate. |
| Public Visibility | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill makes the governing application, notice, responsible actors, identification status, and transition consequences sufficiently identifiable through written applications, clerk notices, prescribed forms, public facility-visit lists, and the existing election-law framework. |
| Review and Correction Availability | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill preserves written elector notifications, permits an elector to request continued service after a missed ballot, permits an elector to end service, and leaves the existing statutory election-administration and legal-review structure in place. |
| Affected-Public Inclusion | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill addresses electors using automatic absentee ballots, existing indefinitely confined electors during transition, electors with disabilities who need assistance transmitting identification, residents of covered facilities, and municipal election administrators within the bill’s defined scope. |
| Institutional Continuity | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — section 19 supplies a transition notice and conversion route for existing indefinitely confined electors, while section 20 establishes the January 1, 2029 transition date and preserves the existing statutory structures not altered by the bill. |
| Interpret | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill defines the statewide voter registration system, identifies the applicable automatic-ballot provisions, and supplies conforming references for the repeal of indefinitely confined status and the replacement procedure. |
| Delegate | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill assigns bounded execution responsibilities to municipal clerks, the Elections Commission, authorized disability advocates, and special voting deputies without transferring the underlying legislative authority or removing statutory limits. |
| Implement | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill converts the stated policy into applications, proof-of-identification verification, automatic ballot delivery, expiration notices, discontinuation procedures, transition notices, and assistance records. |
| Disclose | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill requires notices to affected electors, requires public availability of certain special-voting-deputy information, and specifies retention of identification records for administration of the automatic-ballot process without altering the packet’s existing confidentiality rules. |
| Review | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill requires clerks to monitor eligibility, address, ballot return, identification expiration, and elector requests, and requires notice when automatic service is discontinued without the elector’s request. |
| Correct | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill supplies corrective routes through elector notification, renewed proof of identification, written requests to continue service, written requests to discontinue service, and the existing statutory mechanisms for correcting election-administration actions. |
| Include | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill expressly incorporates electors requiring disability assistance and residents of qualified facilities into the operative automatic-ballot and absentee-voting procedures without expanding the defined beneficiary class beyond the bill’s subject. |
| Preserve | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill preserves application records, identification-related records during the authorized period, transition information, existing election procedures, and continuing duties through the change taking effect on January 1, 2029. |

All criteria: 🟢=18 | 🟡=0 | 🔴=0

## Proposed Amendments

No amendment is required by the analysis.

## Plain-Language Summary

The bill changes how eligible Wisconsin voters receive absentee ballots automatically. Beginning January 1, 2029, the existing indefinitely confined voter process ends, and a voter who wants ballots automatically for every election must submit a written application and valid proof of identification to the municipal clerk. The clerk must send ballots under the new process, stop sending them when the voter is no longer eligible or does not return a ballot, and notify the voter when service is stopped without the voter’s request. A voter may ask to continue receiving ballots after missing one and may ask to stop receiving them or must notify the clerk after moving.

Municipal clerks must notify current indefinitely confined voters about the change and explain how to use the new process before the transition date. Clerks must retain identification copies for the authorized period and notify voters when replacement identification is required. An authorized disability advocate may help a voter with a disability transmit identification, but knowingly sending fraudulent identification in that role is made a felony. Under the supplied record, no additional correction is required for the bill to carry its stated intent through its operative legal structure.

## Final Assessment

✅ ALIGNED

The controlling evidence is the amendatory text that repeals the indefinitely confined process, establishes the replacement automatic-ballot application, assigns implementation duties, provides transition notices, and supplies identification, discontinuation, assistance, and enforcement rules. The two amendments to the automatic-ballot subsection operate as conforming amendments: the later text removes the obsolete reference to repealed indefinitely confined status and leaves a determinate replacement procedure. The supplied sources do not establish administrative capacity, fiscal effects, the number of affected voters, or the practical effects on ballot access; those limitations do not establish a coherence defect.
