CLEAR Analysis
Historical example · Wisconsin Senate Bill 597 (2025–2026)
Policy Summary
SB597 would have created a continuing application for automatic absentee-ballot delivery and ended the indefinitely confined process beginning January 1, 2029. It assigned application, identification, records and notice duties to election officials, allowed specified disability advocates to help transmit identification, and proposed a Class I felony for knowingly transmitting fraudulent identification in that role. The bill failed; these changes did not take effect through SB597.
Source clarification before reading the historical findings
The original analysis questioned the connection between every written continuing application and the bill’s fax/email identification provision. Full surrounding law was omitted from its packet. At the bill’s introduction, section 6.87(1) already supplied a general identification rule for absentee applications, subject to the statutory exceptions and alternatives. Proposed section 6.86(1)(ad)1 instead gives a specific electronic-retention and expiry-notice duty for identification received under paragraph (ac), the fax/email pathway. The historical yellow finding below records the earlier limited-context assessment; it does not establish that written applications lacked an identification rule.
Recorded findings on the introduced text
These 18 rows preserve the original findings and rationales. The source clarification above is separate from that historical assessment.
| Criterion | Result | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Legitimate Authority | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the legislature expressly creates, amends, and repeals election-law provisions, while municipal clerks and the Elections Commission act only under the specified statutory assignments. |
| Institutional Administration | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill assigns application processing, identification retention, notices, ballot delivery, discontinuation, and form-prescription duties to existing election institutions without an evidenced institutional contradiction. |
| Public Accountability | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill preserves clerk administration, election records, public facility-visit lists, existing election-official duties, and the general legal enforcement structure, with no evidenced contradiction in public answerability. |
| Authority Traceability | 🔴 RED | Applicable — the January 1, 2029 version of the continuing-application provision contains the operative text “receives an absentee ballot s. 6.22 (4) or 6.24 (4) (c),” leaving the statutory cross-reference and the resulting exclusion rule legally indeterminate. |
| Purpose-Execution Alignment | 🟡 YELLOW | Applicable — the bill's identification-dependent automatic-ballot structure is implemented through the proof-retention rule for an application under the electronic-mail provision, but the relationship between that provision and every written automatic-ballot application requires interpretation or conforming implementation. |
| Bounded Exercise of Power | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — automatic delivery is limited to electors who apply, remain eligible, remain at the stated address, and continue to qualify under the statute, while clerks must discontinue delivery on specified events. |
| Public Visibility | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill requires notices to affected indefinitely confined electors, expiration notices for retained identification, records of disability-advocate assistance, and existing public availability of certain residential-facility voting information. |
| Review and Correction Availability | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill preserves written notice, elector communications to discontinue or resume automatic delivery, existing election administration, and the ordinary legal mechanisms governing election-law enforcement; no bill-created final bar to lawful correction is evidenced. |
| Affected-Public Inclusion | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill expressly addresses electors formerly using indefinitely confined status, electors seeking continuing absentee delivery, electors with disabilities using authorized assistance, and occupants of covered residential facilities. |
| Institutional Continuity | 🔴 RED | Applicable — the notification provision states that indefinitely confined electors will cease receiving ballots under the prior provision on that subsection's effective date, while the separate effective-date provision delays repeal and related amendments until January 1, 2029, producing an unresolved transition state. |
| Interpret | 🔴 RED | Applicable — interpretation is materially activated by the malformed later amendment to the continuing-application provision and by the inconsistent transition language, but those texts do not yield a determinate statutory relationship without supplying a disposition or conforming reading. |
| Delegate | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill assigns bounded execution to municipal clerks, the Elections Commission, and authorized disability advocates while preserving statutory responsibility and specified records and penalties. |
| Implement | 🟡 YELLOW | Applicable — clerks must implement automatic delivery while the bill's later continuing-application text and the delayed repeal create an unresolved sequence concerning which application exclusion and which prior status govern at each effective date. |
| Disclose | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill activates notices and record transmission, and it specifies the identification-retention period and the contents and timing of the disability-advocate assistance record without an evidenced contradiction in the disclosure relationship. |
| Review | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — clerks must verify identification, receive elector notices, discontinue or resume delivery under stated conditions, and maintain records, so the bill activates review without evidencing a contradictory review rule. |
| Correct | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill permits discontinuation, renewal after a missed ballot, replacement of expired identification, and legislative amendment or repeal through ordinary legal authority; no correction route activated by the text is unusable on the supplied record. |
| Include | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the operative provisions bring the specified elector categories, disability advocates, clerks, and residential-facility procedures into the governing field without an evidenced silent exclusion required by the bill's own operation. |
| Preserve | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill preserves identification copies for the stated period, assistance records for each election, existing election records, and continuing obligations unless the elector ceases to qualify or the proof expires. |
Original recommendations and drafting decisions
The original amendment review authorized restoring “under” in section 9 and specifying January 1, 2029 in the section 19 transition notice. It left the identification-link recommendation unresolved and did not draft it. R1 also introduced an extra comma in section 8. The next reading recorded 17 green and 1 yellow, identifying the incomplete phrase “in his or capacity.” Cycle 2 added “her” and removed a page-header artifact. R2 then received three consecutive 18-green readings on its historical packet.
Publication review and R3
The source review clarifies the identification relationship without adding a new blanket requirement. R3 reverses only the extra section 8 comma, restoring the original conjunction. It retains the section 9, section 19 and section 17 repairs. Three new readings against the expanded historical statute context each returned 18 green, 0 yellow and 0 red. Both the R2 history and this separate R3 validation are available in the walkthrough.
Recorded assessment
🔴 STRUCTURAL MISALIGNED
This is the preserved assessment of the introduced bill. The new qualification applies to proposed R3. This published historical example preserves the introduced bill and the separate CLEAR drafts.
Sources and scope
SB597 failed to pass on March 23, 2026 and was not enacted. The official bill PDF was retrieved again on October 19, 2026 and is byte-identical to the retained copy; the refreshed official history confirms the failed status. CLEAR’s revisions are proposals, not amendments adopted by the Legislature. R1, R2 and R3 identify successive CLEAR drafts based on the introduced bill.
The original identification-link recommendation was not drafted. The historical packets omitted full sections 6.86 and 6.87; the first also omitted section 50.065. References to those identification rules describe the law reviewed for the bill’s October 30, 2025 introduction. A separate source review now distinguishes the general identification rule in section 6.87(1), its exceptions including section 6.87(4)(b)3, and the fax/email provision in section 6.86(1)(ac). The proposed electronic-retention and expiry-notice rule refers specifically to that fax/email pathway. It should not be described as a new universal retention or resubmission requirement.
R3 restores the original “or” in the section 8 reference list, reversing the extra comma introduced in R1. No other R2 wording was changed. Three fresh consecutive readings of identical R3 text and an expanded, historically checked statute packet each returned 18 green, 0 yellow and 0 red findings with reconciled counts. These results belong to R3 and its packet; they do not replace the original 13-green, 2-yellow, 3-red assessment or the separate R2 record.
The historical finding rows and raw reports remain intact. The original prose tally incorrectly said 14 green; the 18 rows count 13. These edited examples explain the source clarification without silently rewriting those historical findings. The readings assess drafting coherence; they do not establish voter effects, costs, fraud reduction, records security, legislative intent, or the reason the bill failed. This is a historical example, not current voting guidance.
- Official introduced bill: https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/2025/related/proposals/sb597.pdf
- Official bill history: https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/2025/proposals/reg/sen/bill/sb597
- Historical chapter 6: https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/2023/statutes/statutes/6.pdf
- Historical caregiver definition: https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/2023/statutes/statutes/50.pdf