Recorded assessment
Policy Summary
The bill replaces the existing indefinitely confined voter absentee-ballot process beginning January 1, 2029, while creating a general application process through which an elector may automatically receive an absentee ballot for every election held in the elector’s municipality. The elector must provide proof of identification, notify the municipal clerk of an address change or decision to stop receiving automatic ballots, and remain eligible under the applicable absentee-voting provisions. Municipal clerks must retain an electronic copy of the proof of identification in the statewide voter registration system until the elector stops receiving automatic ballots or the proof expires, and must notify the elector when renewed proof is needed. The bill also requires clerks to notify current indefinitely confined voters of the transition and permits an authorized disability advocate to transmit proof of identification for an elector with a disability. A knowingly fraudulent transmission by an authorized disability advocate is made a Class I felony.
The operative institutions are the legislature, the Wisconsin Elections Commission, municipal clerks or boards of election commissioners, authorized disability advocates, and the existing election administration and criminal-enforcement structures. The governed population consists of electors using automatic absentee-ballot delivery, current indefinitely confined voters transitioning to the new process, electors in residential care facilities and retirement homes, and electors with disabilities receiving assistance from authorized advocates. The bill supplies application, notification, identification-retention, ballot-delivery, and penalty mechanisms. The supplied sources do not establish the fiscal effect, implementation capacity of the statewide voter registration system, the number of affected electors, or whether every elector can practically obtain qualifying proof of identification. Those are evidence limitations, not coherence findings.
One operative drafting circumstance requires investigation: proposed s. 12.13 (6) provides, “No person in his or capacity as an authorized disability advocate,” omitting a grammatically necessary term after “or.” The provision’s subject, prohibited conduct, and cross-reference are otherwise identifiable, but the exact formulation of the capacity restriction should be clarified.
---
Review Findings
| Criterion | Result | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Legitimate Authority | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill exercises legislative authority by amending and creating specified election statutes and assigns implementation to identified election institutions within the stated election-law domain. |
| Institutional Administration | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill assigns application processing, ballot delivery, notification, identification retention, and advocate-record duties to municipal clerks, the commission, and existing election officials, and the packet establishes no contradiction in that implementation structure. |
| Public Accountability | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill requires notice to transitioning electors, preserves existing election administration duties, and places the new identification and advocate provisions within existing statutory enforcement structures. |
| Authority Traceability | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the material powers and duties are located in identified statutory sections and assigned to the legislature, commission, municipal clerks, and authorized disability advocates within stated limits. |
| Purpose-Execution Alignment | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the automatic-ballot mechanism, identification requirement, transition notice, and advocate-assistance provisions directly implement the stated change from indefinitely confined status to an identification-based automatic-delivery process. |
| Bounded Exercise of Power | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — automatic delivery is limited to electors who apply, provide proof of identification, remain qualified, and comply with address and discontinuation duties, while advocate assistance is limited to transmitting identification for an elector with a disability. |
| Public Visibility | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — material application, notice, identification-retention, advocate-record, and ballot-delivery duties are stated in the operative text, and the bill preserves public availability of existing residential-facility voting information. |
| Review and Correction Availability | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill does not foreclose existing lawful election review, enforcement, or correction structures, and its discontinuation and renewal provisions provide operative routes for correcting automatic-delivery status. |
| Affected-Public Inclusion | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill expressly governs current indefinitely confined voters, electors using automatic absentee delivery, electors with disabilities receiving advocate assistance, and electors in residential care facilities or retirement homes within the bill’s stated scope. |
| Institutional Continuity | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill provides a January 1, 2029 transition, requires notice to current indefinitely confined voters, permits qualifying voters to convert to the new process, and preserves the continuing duties of clerks and election institutions. |
| Interpret | 🟡 YELLOW | Applicable — proposed s. 12.13 (6) activates interpretation of a criminal prohibition on an authorized disability advocate, but the phrase “in his or capacity” is grammatically incomplete and requires clarification of the capacity limitation without establishing a contradiction in the broader statutory purpose. |
| Delegate | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill permits a defined authorized disability advocate to transmit a voter’s proof of identification while preserving the elector’s application purpose, advocate-record duty, and criminal prohibition against knowingly transmitting fraudulent proof. |
| Implement | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill converts its automatic-ballot policy into clerk duties for applications, ballot delivery, identification retention, expiration notices, transition notices, and residential-facility administration. |
| Disclose | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill requires clerks to provide transition and expiration notices and advocates to maintain and provide assistance records, while the identification-retention rule is limited to the statewide voter registration system and the period specified by the bill. |
| Review | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill activates continuing clerk determinations concerning elector eligibility, address status, identification validity, ballot return, and whether automatic delivery should continue. |
| Correct | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill supplies operative correction routes through elector notifications, clerk discontinuation of delivery, renewed proof of identification, and conversion from the repealed indefinitely confined process to the new application process. |
| Include | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill includes the affected voter categories and disability-assistance relationship that its automatic-ballot structure expressly governs, without requiring expansion beyond that scope. |
| Preserve | 🟢 GREEN | Applicable — the bill preserves relevant voter-status information, identification records for the specified period, advocate assistance records, transition duties, and existing election-administration responsibilities across the 2029 change. |
---
Proposed Amendments
Amendment 1
Separate issue: None after the specified textual clarification.
Replace the phrase “No person in his or capacity as an authorized disability advocate under s. 6.86 (1) (ad) 2. may knowingly transmit” in proposed s. 12.13 (6) with a grammatically complete formulation such as “No person in his or her capacity as an authorized disability advocate under s. 6.86 (1) (ad) 2. may knowingly transmit.” This is the least-sufficient change because it directly clarifies the incomplete capacity phrase, preserves the stated anti-fraud purpose, leaves the defined advocate class unchanged, and does not expand the bill’s authority, duties, penalty, or affected population.
Proposed amendments: 1.
---
Plain-Language Summary
The bill would end the existing indefinitely confined absentee-voter process on January 1, 2029 and replace it with a process under which a voter may apply to receive an absentee ballot automatically for every election in the voter’s municipality. The voter must provide qualifying identification, and municipal clerks must send the ballots, retain the identification for the specified period, notify voters when identification expires, and stop sending ballots when the voter is no longer eligible, changes address, or asks to stop.
Current indefinitely confined voters must be notified that they will need to use the new process and submit valid identification before the transition date. A defined disability advocate may help transmit identification for a voter with a disability, and the advocate must keep an assistance record. The bill also creates a felony for knowingly transmitting fraudulent identification in that role. The smallest correction still required is to complete the phrase “in his or capacity” in that felony provision so that the person’s covered legal capacity is stated clearly.
---
Final Assessment
⚠️ CONDITIONALLY ALIGNED — at least one element remains YELLOW and none remains RED.
The operative amendments establish a generally coherent transition from indefinitely confined absentee voting to identification-based automatic absentee-ballot delivery. The controlling non-green evidence is the incomplete phrase in proposed s. 12.13 (6), which affects interpretation of the new advocate-related criminal prohibition but does not establish a contradiction in the bill’s broader structure. The restoration path is a narrow textual clarification of that phrase. The supplied sources do not establish fiscal effects, implementation capacity, the number of affected voters, or practical access to qualifying identification; those remain evidence limitations rather than coherence defects.